When I started this Substack, I did so for a fairly simple reason. I wanted a place to share my thoughts, experiences, observations, and lessons learned in a way that reflected who I am and what I believe matters.
For much of my adult life, I have tried to live by a straightforward personal mission: Help people. Solve problems. Be a great teammate on better teams.
That mission has shaped how I approach leadership, business, community involvement, relationships, and just about everything else I do. It is also what I wanted this publication to represent.
I didn’t start writing because I believe I have all the answers. Quite the opposite. The older I get, the more I recognize how much I don’t know, how often my own assumptions have been wrong, and how important it is to remain curious.
I believe many of our greatest problems persist not because solutions are beyond our reach, but because we are unwilling to put in the effort required to understand the problems in the first place.
We become attached to what we think we know. We surround ourselves with people who reinforce those beliefs. We mistake confidence for understanding, popularity for credibility, and disagreement for hostility.
And increasingly, we allow technology and algorithms to do much of that work for us.
My goal with this publication has never been to tell people what to think. It has been to encourage people, myself included, to think more critically about what they believe, why they believe it, and whether those beliefs hold up under scrutiny.
Sometimes that means challenging conventional wisdom. Sometimes it means asking uncomfortable questions. Sometimes it means acknowledging that the popular position is correct. And sometimes it means discovering that something I believed strongly was simply wrong.
I want people to disagree with me. I want them to challenge my assumptions, question my conclusions, and point out things I may have overlooked.
But I want them to do it thoughtfully.
Because disagreement, when approached with curiosity and intellectual honesty, is one of the most valuable tools we have for learning.
Unfortunately, something I experienced this past week reminded me just how far we have drifted from that understanding.
The Data Center Debate That Wasn’t Really About Data Centers
Yesterday, I published an article about data centers and the growing controversy surrounding proposed facilities in West Michigan.
My premise was fairly straightforward.
Data centers have existed in this country for decades. They are not a new invention, and their presence is not evidence of some newly emerging technological threat. What has changed is their scale, their resource requirements, where they are being proposed, and, perhaps most noticeably, the amount of public attention they are receiving.
I wanted to explore those differences while asking a broader question: How much of our concern is the result of independently examining the facts, and how much is the result of being repeatedly exposed to something through our personal and online feeds?
I referenced historical information, federal research, and industry data to explain how these facilities have evolved.
I also acknowledged that the increasing demand for electricity, water, and physical infrastructure creates legitimate questions for communities considering new developments.
In fact, a substantial portion of the article was dedicated to identifying the questions township boards, local officials, and residents should be asking before approving a project.
Who pays for the electrical infrastructure? What are the actual water requirements? What happens during peak demand? How much noise will cooling equipment generate? What are the long-term financial benefits, and who bears the costs?
I explicitly stated that some proposed projects may not make sense for the communities considering them and should be rejected.
It was not an argument for blindly supporting data centers.
It was an argument for understanding them before deciding whether to support or oppose them.
And then I shared it on social media.
When We Respond to What We Assume Instead of What Was Written
The response was interesting, although not entirely surprising.
One commenter challenged the idea that social media had much to do with the growing concern, arguing that the scale and potential consequences of these projects had changed dramatically and that residents’ concerns deserved to be taken seriously.
I agree with both observations.
In fact, I had made those very points in the article.
The fact that modern facilities are getting larger and more resource-intensive was part of the discussion, not something I had ignored.
But that distinction seemed to get lost.
The same commenter went on to suggest that older data centers connect to the electrical grid much like a large retail store, while newer AI facilities require something closer to their own power plants.
That comparison was an oversimplification of the history and engineering involved.
Major data centers have required substantial electrical infrastructure for years. The Switch facility near Grand Rapids, which has been operating since 2017, is one local example.
An electrical worker who helped construct the primary and standby power infrastructure at that facility joined the discussion and explained that dedicated high-voltage infrastructure and industrial-scale backup generation were already part of these developments long before the current AI boom.
That does not mean the demands of new AI facilities are insignificant. They can be enormous, and in some cases materially different from what came before.
But the existence of those differences does not make the history irrelevant.
We should be capable of acknowledging that something has changed without pretending that everything preceding it was fundamentally different.
That is how we develop an accurate understanding of an issue.
Another commenter took a different approach.
Rather than discussing the data, the infrastructure, or the questions I had raised, he questioned my motives.
He accused me of diverting attention from the issue, engaging in watered-down environmental and public health antagonism, and simply creating content to promote my social media presence and personal brand.
I found that response particularly revealing.
Not because someone questioned my intentions. Anyone who publishes an opinion publicly should expect scrutiny, including questions about their motivations.
But because the criticism largely avoided engaging with the actual argument.
An article encouraging residents to examine environmental, infrastructure, and financial concerns before making decisions was being characterized as antagonistic to those very concerns.
Apparently, encouraging people to ask better questions was not enough.
I was expected to arrive at a particular conclusion, express the appropriate level of outrage, and reinforce what others had already decided was true.
And because I didn’t, the assumption became that I must have some ulterior motive.
We Have Confused Disagreement With Opposition
This is where the issue becomes much larger than data centers.
Somewhere along the way, we have developed a troubling tendency to interpret anything short of complete agreement as opposition.
If someone raises a concern about a proposed development, we assume they oppose economic growth.
If someone questions an environmental claim, we assume they don’t care about the environment.
If someone challenges a popular narrative, we assume they are defending whatever person, business, or institution that narrative is directed against.
And if someone asks us to substantiate our claims, we sometimes interpret that request as a personal attack.
We have created an environment where the position someone is perceived to hold matters more than the substance of what they are saying.
This is particularly dangerous because it discourages the very behavior we should be encouraging.
Curiosity.
Skepticism.
Intellectual humility.
The willingness to say, “I hadn’t considered that,” or “I may have been wrong.”
Instead, we reward certainty, even when it is unsupported. We celebrate the person who delivers the sharpest insult rather than the person who asks the most useful question.
We increasingly approach conversations as competitions to be won rather than opportunities to understand something.
And when winning becomes the objective, learning becomes optional.
The Algorithm Doesn’t Have to Make Us Stupid. We Do That Ourselves.
I write frequently about our relationship with technology because I believe we have become far too comfortable allowing it to influence what we notice, what we believe, and how we respond.
Social media algorithms do not necessarily need to convince us that something false is true.
Often, all they need to do is repeatedly direct our attention toward something that generates an emotional response.
A controversial development. A political statement. A business decision. A public figure saying something offensive.
Once something appears in our feeds often enough, it begins to feel disproportionately important. We see other people expressing outrage, and that outrage helps establish how we are expected to respond.
Before long, we may have formed a strong opinion about something we knew very little about a week earlier.
And once we have publicly committed to that opinion, changing our minds becomes increasingly uncomfortable.
Our position is no longer just an interpretation of the facts.
It becomes part of our identity.
Psychologists have studied versions of this phenomenon for years, including motivated reasoning and identity-protective cognition. We have a tendency to accept information that supports what we already believe while scrutinizing or dismissing information that threatens those beliefs.
Algorithms can amplify that tendency by repeatedly surrounding us with narratives that reinforce our existing assumptions.
But here is the part I think we need to take greater responsibility for.
The algorithm may influence what we see, but we remain responsible for what we choose to believe.
We decide whether to read beyond the headline.
We decide whether to examine the evidence.
We decide whether to ask a question or simply repeat an accusation.
We decide whether to treat a person who disagrees with us as someone who might teach us something or as someone who must be defeated.
Technology can make intellectual laziness easier. It does not make it inevitable.
And blaming the algorithm for our unwillingness to think is just another way of avoiding responsibility.
What Happens When We Stop Being Curious?
I have spent much of my professional life solving problems.
One of the most important lessons I have learned is that the quality of a solution is directly related to how well we understand the problem.
If we define the problem incorrectly, even an exceptionally well-executed solution can make things worse.
Yet we routinely do the opposite in public discourse.
We identify something that makes us uncomfortable, immediately decide who or what is responsible, and then begin advocating for a solution before we have established what is actually happening.
We skip the uncomfortable work of investigation.
We rarely ask what information might change our minds.
And we seem increasingly unwilling to distinguish between something we know, something we suspect, and something we simply feel.
Consider the data center debate.
A community might reasonably conclude that a proposed facility would place an unacceptable burden on its electrical infrastructure, water resources, or residents.
That would be a legitimate conclusion if supported by the facts.
A different community might determine that its proposed project includes adequate infrastructure investments, enforceable environmental protections, and sufficient economic benefits to justify approval.
That could also be a legitimate conclusion.
The two decisions need not be contradictory because the circumstances may be different.
But to reach either conclusion responsibly, someone has to do the work.
Someone has to read the documents, understand the engineering, examine the financial assumptions, and ask questions that cannot be answered by a catchy social media post.
Most importantly, someone has to be willing to discover that their initial assumptions were wrong.
That requires considerably more effort than simply choosing a side.
And I worry that we are becoming a society increasingly unwilling to make that effort.
Criticism Is Welcome. Intellectual Laziness Shouldn’t Be.
I want to make something clear.
I am not suggesting that people who disagreed with my article are wrong simply because they disagreed.
Nor am I suggesting that my original article was beyond criticism.
If I presented an inaccurate statistic, tell me.
If I misunderstood a technical requirement, explain it.
If I overlooked an environmental concern, bring it forward.
If there is compelling evidence that challenges my conclusion, I want to see it.
Those are precisely the conversations I hoped to encourage when I started writing.
I have no interest in being surrounded by people who simply tell me I am right. That may be comfortable, but it is not particularly useful.
What I find troubling is our increasing willingness to substitute assumptions about someone’s character or motivations for an actual examination of their argument.
We should also recognize that this is not a problem confined to one political party, generation, ideology, or side of a particular issue.
It is a human problem.
And I am not immune to it.
I have my own biases, preconceived notions, and opinions shaped by experience. I have certainly responded to things emotionally and formed conclusions before having all the information.
The difference I am trying to cultivate in myself, and encourage in others, is the willingness to recognize when that happens and correct it.
Being wrong is not a character flaw.
Being unwilling to consider that you might be wrong is a much more serious problem.
The Purpose Was Never Agreement
The reaction to my data center article ultimately reinforced the reason I started this Substack.
We don’t need more people telling us what we already believe.
We don’t need more outrage, more certainty, or more carefully curated narratives designed to reassure us that our side is right and everyone else is foolish.
We need people willing to ask questions.
We need people comfortable enough with uncertainty to admit what they don’t know.
We need people willing to challenge their own assumptions as vigorously as they challenge those of others.
And we need to remember that the purpose of a disagreement should not always be to change the other person’s mind.
Sometimes the most valuable outcome is that both people leave the conversation understanding something they didn’t understand before.
I will continue writing about leadership, responsibility, technology, community, business, and the many other issues I find worth exploring.
Some articles will challenge popular opinions. Others may reinforce them. Some will undoubtedly contain conclusions that I later reconsider as I learn more.
That is part of the process.
I don’t expect everyone to agree with me, and I certainly don’t want people agreeing simply because they like me or identify with something I have written before.
I would much rather have someone thoughtfully explain why I am wrong than have a hundred people tell me I am right without understanding why.
Because my goal was never to build an audience that thinks like I do.
It was to encourage an audience that thinks for itself.
And if we cannot have a thoughtful discussion about something as tangible as a proposed data center without immediately questioning one another’s motives, imagining arguments that were never made, or retreating into the comfort of our preferred narratives, we have a much larger problem than where the next industrial facility gets built.
The greatest danger isn’t that technology is becoming capable of thinking for us.
It is that we are becoming increasingly comfortable letting it.
And that is a problem no algorithm, politician, business leader, or technological advancement is going to solve for us.
We have to decide that thinking for ourselves is worth the effort.



